Nothing new (or good) to report. I mean, I probably do, but no one reads this anyway so as far as I know no one cares. More Critical Thinking to follow.
Week #4
I find that with every week I am learning a new side of history that has never before been taught to me. When Dr. Steel started off the week with the question, “Why did Christopher Columbus sail?” I was quick to avoid the elementary answer of “To prove the world was round.” I didn't know that, at that time, educated people (clergy, the courts, etc.) had known the world was round for quite some time. When it was explained however, the connection was instant. The Age of Exploration took place during the Renaissance, which was a period of cultural rebirth. The Church no longer had complete control over society, and Ancient Greek and Roman literature, culture, and science were re-introduced into the world. The Ancient Greeks knew the world was round and, once the Renaissance had begun, so did the educated people of Western Europe.
So why did Columbus sail? The seemingly unanimous answer of the class was “To find a faster passage to the Indies for trade.” Which was.....sort of right, according to Dr. Steel. He then told us about the Silk Road, which was a land route for trade between Asia, Europe, and the Middle East. When the Middle East (who pretty much controlled trade between Asia and Europe, because everything passed through them both ways) started enacting taxes or tributes in order to further secure their hold on the trade route, the leaders of Europe (the Pope, mostly) decided to start what they called the Crusades in order to “take back the Holy Land,” and also to take over the Middle East and control the trade route, because a land route was faster and more direct than a seaward route around the horn of Africa.
Christopher Columbus had this radical idea that the world was actually about half the size the Greeks claimed it was. Which was why Italy, Spain, and Portugal all denied Columbus a charter to sail around the world. It was only after King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella were married and Spain was united under the Catholic Church (and all the Jews and Muslims who had been thriving in Spain had been driven off the Iberian Peninsula) that Columbus finally was granted permission to sail in search of a new trade route, and to hopefully prove his theory about the size of the world.
Unfortunately for Columbus, things didn't exactly go as planned. His math may have been correct, because he did hit land where he had hypothesized he would. However he soon realized that wherever he was was certainly not any part of Asia. There was no silk, no spices, nothing that had been brought to Europe by the Silk Road. Oops. Desperate, Columbus searched for anything of value that could be sent back. He finally decided to send the natives themselves, as slaves. Many of them had already died of smallpox, to which the Europeans had developed an immunity and of which most were carriers. Many more would die on the overseas journey due to harsh conditions, illnesses, and some threw themselves overboard to escape. Many still died upon reaching Europe, simply because they had been separated from their homeland.
Then we were posed with a more difficult question. Why didn't the Europeans get sick from Native diseases when the Native Americans were brought over? Dr. Steel told us that, along with the fact that there were no deadly epidemics in North America and the North Americans valued hygiene and had healthier diets, a major reason why the Europeans always got sick and the Native Americans did not is due to the fact that Europeans had domesticated animals. They were surrounded every day by dirty living conditions and dirty farm animals, even in the cities. The Native Americans couldn't even think to domesticate or “enslave” creatures who they considered their “brothers.”
The Europeans and Native Americans had very dissonant cultures. The Europeans were in a constant power struggle with one another. Europe was a very materialistic culture. They had to own things in order to feel and be powerful. The Native Americans had no concept of ownership. They thought the Europeans were merely asking to use the land, while the Europeans thought they Native Americans were selling them the land. The Native Americans had no idea why it would be necessary to sign a paper to be able to simply use the land. They called the Europeans “those who speak with forked tongues,” because they also had no word for or concept of lying. They thought the Europeans were speaking out of different sides of their mouth. They didn't understand why someone would want to say something but really mean something different.
In the short run, “discovering” the New World brought a great deal of wealth to Spain. For a long time, they were one of the great super powers of Europe. In the long run however, Spain became greatly impoverished and their power was toppled after the Spanish Armada suffered an embarrassing defeat by the tiny (in comparison) British Royal Navy.
Dr. Steel continued his lecture on the waning power of Spain with the Mexican for for independence from Spain. Mexico won its independence in 1810. After which, there have been a long series of revolutions. The most notable of which was led by Pancho Villa and Emiliano Zapata in 1910, in order to overthrow the dictator Porfirio Diaz.
In 1994, Mexico, Canada, and the United States formed the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) which supported duty-free trade among the three nations. However, some trade barriers still existed without them being tariffs or taxes, because many people within their respective countries were against importing goods that can be grown, raised, or manufactured domestically. Worried about their suffering businesses and being pushed off the land that their ancestors had lived on and used for centuries, indigenous Mexicans (of Mayan descent, for example) have been and still are fighting against trade barriers and especially NAFTA. Even today, the indigenous people of Mexico have no concept of ownership, and don't understand why they cannot use the land of their ancestors that isn't even being used by the wealthy plantation owners who “own” the land.
The point of that day's lecture was to stress the importance of reading into the background and context of information that is given. Chapter 5 of the Paul and Elder book discusses the “Standards for Thinking.” By looking deeper into a less-known side of history, we are bringing “Clarity” to a situation that is occurring this very day. We are also checking the “Accuracy” of the most common answers to seemingly well-known questions, such as “Why did Christopher Columbus sail?” The answer “To prove the earth was round” is a very clear answer, along with “To find a faster trade route to Asia or the East Indies.” However, neither of those statements are truly accurate. To find the most accurate answer, we had to trace history back to the Renaissance Period and consider what society knew to be true and false back then. The more details we discussed, the more “Precise” our answers became. Yet, from a Critical Thinking perspective, it remains difficult to understand the cultural issues of an indigenous people with different values from our own. It's hard for someone like myself to imagine living in a culture with no concept of ownership or dishonesty, which are concepts I've lived with and grown used to my whole life.
Wednesday brought up one of the most interesting lectures to date. We began discussing Eastern thought. “What is the point of separation between us in here, and the trees outside?” we were asked. After a long stream of seemingly unsuccessful suggestions, we came to the conclusion that there really is no point of separation between us and a tree. Not that we are the same things, but that we depend on one another for survival.
According to the Watts textbook, there are “two philosophical traditions playing complementary parts [in Eastern thought]- Confucianism and Taoism...Confucianism...preoccupies itself with conventional knowledge...The individual defines himself and his place in society in terms of the Confucian formulae...Taoism, on the other hand...concerns itself with unconventional knowledge, with the understanding of life directly, instead of in the abstract, linear terms of representational thinking (page 10).” In other words, Confucianism provides a conventional structure (much like Western thought) for a well-functioning society, while Taoism is kind of like a “rebellion” against that structure. Watts continuously uses the word “spontaneity,” which I came to suddenly realize meant simply letting thoughts or actions happen, rather than willing them to (Like meditation is allowing the mind to wander where it will rather than where one wants it to go. It isn't essentially “clearing” one's mind, it's “releasing” it from its bond to you.) . Spontaneity is or is a result of the Tao.
If there is no point of separation between a human and a tree, why does the human cut down the tree and build with its wood instead of using parts from other humans and animals? After an arduous and complex debate, we came to a seemingly obvious conclusion. Humans do not make their own food (We do not photosynthesize), therefore we are compelled to kill other living things in order to survive.
Where Eastern and Western Thought Divide:
Eastern and Western thought are similar in that they contain some form of conventional thought. However, while Western thought is completely made up of convention and structure, Eastern thought does not. Eastern thought has the Tao; that small rebellion against convention. The “slogan” of Taoist perception is “Everything, all at once, forever.” That is the definition of Reality and Truth. The Reality and Truth that is absolute and cannot be perceived all at once vs. the reality and truth of convention which Western thought is based upon.
From here we moved on to perception. As humans, we can only perceive a small range of our senses. For example, on the electromagnetic spectrum, the range of light which humans can see (visible light) is tiny in comparison to the entire spectrum. We can only taste things that are water-soluble. We can only touch things that are so hot or so cold before the extreme temperatures prevent us from having any tactile senses at all. There is so much more “out there” that the human being cannot perceive that it is impossible to believe that everything we CAN perceive is all that exists.
Another difference between Eastern and Western thought is hubris vs. humility. Hubris is a word that stems from Ancient Greece. Essentially, it means a great pride or overconfidence in oneself that eventually leads to a downfall. Hubris is present in many Greek myths, but especially in the story of Icarus, who longed to fly. But when his father made him and himself wings, Icarus's hubris took over. He longed to touch the sun, so he flew higher and higher. Then, Icarus got too close to the sun. The wax on his wings melted. Icarus fell into the sea below and died. That is hubris, essentially, which can be found within those who use primarily or only Western thought.
Comparatively, Eastern thought focuses on the word “humility.” For those who use Eastern thought, humility is the ability to admit that they are human and therefore does not know everything. Hubris vs. humility can also be explained as:
“If I can conceive it, then it is the Truth.” -Western thought
vs.
“There is too much for one person to perceive everything and consider it the Truth.” -Eastern thought.
Eastern thinkers perceive the world not as “things,” but as a “process.” There is no easy way to explain this process, but Dr. Steel summed it up by saying “The way that can be named is not the true way.” If there is a name for the process you're thinking of in order to achieve “zen,” then you're not thinking of the right process. The process cannot be named with one name, but rather with proverbs such as, “When I'm not thinking, that is when I am.” They are like hints at how one can achieve the ultimate goal of zen, because the actual “way” cannot be named; cannot be described in a word. It is this type of creed that keeps Eastern and Western thought at odds with one another. Overall, a very diverse week.
This post received all "S"s, so no instructor comments.
Wednesday, March 31, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment