Last semester I took a class called Intro to Critical Thinking. It is required for all Honors Students here at BGSU and I really really learned so much! For the class, we had to write weekly blogs containing a summary of what we learned that week as well as inserting a personal synthesis. (I didn't really have many problems with the synthesis part...I like to talk about myself a lot...heh) The journals were meant to be personal; like an in-depth discussion with Dr. Steel (our professor) and Melanie, our peer facilitator (Kind of like a TA, but she didn't teach).
But anyway, I would really like to share these personal blogs with the public and see what other people think. So, for the next 20 days (one blog a day) here is some insight into my experience with training in Critical Thinking, as well as a lot of my world views. (Okay, and a bit of what the teacher wanted to hear! haha) Please feel free to comment and add your own remarks and questions!
Side note: Sometimes I don't correctly cite the texts we used in class. Dr. Steel did not require that of us since it was a private thing and he knew the texts extensively. So for your reference, here are the texts we used:
-Browne, Neil, and Stuart Keeley. Asking the Right Questions. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson/Prentice Hall.
-Paul, Richard, and Linda Elder. Critical Thinking. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
-Watts, Alan. The Way of Zen. New York: Pamtheon Books, 1957.
-Traven, B. The White Rose. Westport, CT: Lawrence Hill, 1979.
Week #1
“I pledge allegiance to my Flag and the Republic for which it stands, one nation, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all” (Francis Bellamy, 1892). It's amazing that such a simple poem has come to mean so much, and has brought up so much controversy here in the United States. This poem, meant to be recited on Columbus Day, has been changed so much (to a point where Bellamy himself may not even recognize it, were he still alive.) all for the sake of patriotism; nationalism. It is easy to spot the additions today:
“I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America,
And to the Republic for which it stands,
One nation, under God, indivisible,
With liberty and justice for all.”
The first big question: Who made these changes? “...the Flag of the United States of America...” was added in 1924 by the National Flag Conference, which was run by the American Legion and the Daughters of the American Revolution. In 1954, “under God” was added by Congress after much urging from the Knights of Columbus (a bit of a coincidence there, if you ask me, though Christopher Columbus did capture and either slaughter or sell into slavery many hundreds of indigenous Americans “in the name of God...”), making this Pledge of Allegiance not only a patriotic oath but also a “public prayer.”
The second big question: Why were these changes made? In 1924, many hundreds of immigrants flocked to the United States in hope of starting anew. With this surge came also a large anti-immigrant movement. Removing the phrase “my Flag” and adding “the Flag of the United States of America” was thought to prevent unwanted foreigners from claiming the American flag as their own, thus bringing them closer to “true citizenship,” so to speak. This change said, “This flag doesn't belong to any one person, but the to country; to the American people.” The year 1954 was in the midst of the Cold War between the United States and Soviet Russia (or, “Godless Communist Russia”). The addition of “under God” was meant to enforce that God was on “our side,” the United States' side, and not on the side of the USSR. When I learned this, it appeared to me as a slap in the face of the communist nation, which was indeed an atheist nation; a “zinger,” if you will.
Finally, the real big question(s): Why does all this matter? What does this have to do with critical thinking? What seemed to be a history lesson in our first official class of ICT, I realize was actually an important lesson on thinking critically. Learning the true history of the Pledge of Allegiance gave us an opportunity to the another side of history. The side of history that, by now, has faded into legend. As Dr. Steel brought up on Wednesday, you can ask anyone to recite the Pledge and chances are they will, without fail. Ask any one of those who recited it for you to give a brief history of the Pledge, and you can almost bet that they will be unable to. On the other hand, if you ask anyone to recite the Declaration of Independence, some people could only give you one or two lines, but could readily tell you a brief history of the document. Upon hearing this, I was shocked at the reality of that statement. It had never occurred to me that that was true, and yet it is.
An example such as that brings to light the difference between strong-sense and weak-sense critical thinkers; those who use reasons to come to a conclusion (not always the correct conclusion, but in reality, the best conclusion) and those who reach a conclusion based on what they are taught, and only allow certain supporting reasons through their bias to enforce their conclusion. In his book, Asking the Right Questions, Dr. Browne calls the method of the strong-sense thinker the “panning-for-gold” method, and the method of the weak-sense thinker the “sponge” method. On page 4 of ARQ, he writes about the differences between the two methods.
“What does the individual who takes the sponge approach do when he reads material? He reads sentences carefully, trying to remember as much as he can...His mission is to find and understand what the author has to say. He memorizes the reading, but doesn't evaluate it. What does the reader who takes the panning-for-gold approach do? Like the person using the sponge approach, she approaches her reading with the hope that she will acquire new knowledge. There the similarity ends. The panning-for-gold approach requires that the reader ask herself a number of questions designed to uncover the best available decisions or beliefs.” He goes on to say that a reader using the panning-for-gold method often questions the reasoning of the author and makes note of any problems with the author's reasoning.
In the past, especially in school and at home, we have been subjected to weak-sense thinking. We take what we learn from our teachers, parents, and friends and often accept it as the truth, because we are not given another option, or another point of view. Weak-sense thinking is the reason behind the usually unintentional ignorance of a large number of people. I say usually because I am certain that there are those out there who try to be ignorant, and impose their ignorance on others. I know there are people who purposely close their minds to any thought or idea that contradicts their own beliefs. But a good portion of ignorance comes from younger generations, who are learning without having a chance to get a full 360ยบ perspective of what they are learning.
This lesson reminds me of the phrase, “History is written by the victorious.” The winners are the ones who get to write history, and the story of the defeated is pushed into the background until it fades into myth, or is even lost forever. That is something I actually did learn at a young age, and have tried to remember through my learnings. I have tried to remember the other side of the story, but it is difficult when so much of history is overshadowed by the victories of political and other national heroes. The phrase “History is written by the victorious” has always seemed to make sense to me, but I never truly connected with it on a critical thinking level until last Wednesday. Now, as I am reading historical excerpts from my cultural diversity class (as I have posted on the class blog) I find myself examining the writings in-depth and having legitimate issues to discuss in class, sometimes without even realizing that I am doing so.
Such is my reflection on my first week in ICT. I was not expecting a journal entry to be this long, but I have said everything I wanted to say (which I will admit is often a bit excessive for some) and I'm looking forward to class tomorrow!
Comments from Instructors and My Responses:
Melanie Wagner said...
Overall Grade: U
S
S
U - see questions below
S
S
"The addition of “under God” was meant to enforce that God was on “our side,” the United States' side, and not on the side of the USSR. When I learned this, it appeared to me as a slap in the face of the communist nation, which was indeed an atheist nation; a “zinger,” if you will." - If those of the Communist nation did not believe in a god, why would Americans' assertion that the Christian god was on "their" side be a "slap in the face"?
"(not always the correct conclusion, but in reality, the best conclusion)" - do you think there is always a "correct" conclusion?
"But a good portion of ignorance comes from younger generations" - how do you know this?
Haley McClure said...
1.) Perhaps that was not the best thing to say. I feel like it was more of a taunt. The Cold War was a power struggle between the USSR and the United States, who were competing to be the largest and greatest world power. The impression I got was that the United States was trying to prove their "true power" by saying, "We have an omnipotent deity on our side, what do you have? Big guns and spaceships?" So, not exactly a slap in the face, but perhaps an attempt at provocation? I hope that clears that up...
2.) Now that I read that, I don't think I should have put the word "always" there. (This blog will also teach me to proofread my work!) I don't necessarily think there is always a "correct" conclusion. I believe that some conclusions make more sense than others, given the information that I already have and am constantly obtaining. It's also as Dr. Steel has often said in class, that some conclusions can be reached without having to experience them; some conclusions just make sense (i.e. "Don't touch the fire. It's hot and you will get burned."). So no, I don't think there is always a correct conclusion. That was poor wording and proofreading on my part.
3.) I suppose a better sentence would have been "Weak-sense critical thinking starts at a young age." I said this recalling my experiences in elementary school. Elementary school students are not taught how or told to "think critically" about what their teachers teach them. They retain the face value of what they learn and just accept it, because they do not know to analyze or even research "another side" to what they have learned. And if they never learn how to keep an open mind (fair-mindedness) or if they never feel compelled to "look deeper" into what they have been told as truth, then the ignorance will continue throughout their lives (or for as long as they can think). You can't utilize something that you have never learned. They will also never be able to teach their own children (should they ever want to) how to keep an open mind and think critically as they learn in school. The word "ignorance" typically has a negative connotation, but in that sense I did not mean it in a negative way. I was just trying to state something I thought of as fact. A poorly stated fact, I realize.
I hope that clears things up, but I will continue to check back for more questions.
SC Steel said...
Grade: (after revisions) S
S
S
S
S
S
("S" means "satisfactory." "U" means "unsatisfactory")
Friday, March 5, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment