Take Dr. Steel's refrigerator example. One of his child's teachers handed out a paper (a supplies list, perhaps?) that said “Post this on your refrigerator!” Well, Dr. Steel does not have a refrigerator. Now what? The teacher showed some weak thinking by seemingly assuming that because a refrigerator is such a common household appliance, everyone must have one. (This turned on a light in my mind that this too is the way that I think. It seems unreal to me that someone could “survive” without a means to keep foods and drinks fresh and cold, yet I realize that Dr. Steel is not the only person in the world without a refrigerator; he and hundreds of other people around the world get by every day without one.) Paul and Elder would identify this type of thinking as “Stage 1,” or “Unreflective Thinking,” where one is “unaware of significant problems in one's thinking.” Paul and Elder continue with describing this stage by saying:
“...we don't notice that we are continually making assumptions, forming concepts, drawing inferences, and thinking within points of view...Traditional schooling and the way children are typically reared do not help people to become skilled thinkers. Often, parents and teachers themselves are unreflective thinkers.” (pages 26-8)
The way we view the world goes even beyond who does and does not have a refrigerator. As we sat in class and discussed the history of buttons and ties, I was reminded of the history of the Pledge of Allegiance. Hardly anyone knows that buttons were once a status symbol, and that neckties were created to hide one's buttons made of “poor” material. The craftsmanship of today's buttons (often made of plastic) reflects the way buttons looked when they were status symbols, but no one really cares. Buttons and neckties are a part of every day existence, and, as far as I know (which isn't very far), most people merely accept them as such, without knowing the history of today's commonplace items.
Wednesday offered a similar lecture, and yet I still managed to get different information out of it. Influences on thinking was expanded into discussing cultural biases. The big question was: How well can two (or more) different cultures talk about similar things, and understand each other? This question was prefaced with an analogy of a man and a woman who enjoy each others' company and want to expand or deepen their relationship. The majority of the class (or at least, those who spoke up) immediately concluded that Dr. Steel was referring to a marriage proposal, and answered that the man would give the woman a diamond ring (all except one young man who suggested a phone number). The culture my classmates and myself live in has instilled in us a deep emotional attachment or bias towards one person asking another to marry him or her, because these types of relationships are all around us. They are common. We didn't consider that the man might have merely been requesting the woman's partnership in a business or something similar. However, in a different culture, it may be unseemly for someone to actually ask someone else to marry them, because they do not have the right to do so. The marriage proposal, while seemingly obvious to us, would not even cross the minds of someone in another culture. Even giving gifts is different depending on culture. In a modern, money-based society, we more often buy gifts to give to others. Many cultures make gifts to give instead, and in some cultures it is frowned upon to give gifts at all. In ancient Rome, giving gifts between husband and wife was discouraged, so that there wouldn't be any tricky property/ownership issues should a divorce occur.
In the Western culture, thinking is considered and practiced differently than in Eastern culture. I had always known that most textbooks are biased based on the views of the author, but I had never really explored this bias in-depth until Wednesday. Our textbook by Paul and Elder is written with a heavily Western-thinking bias, as we discovered. The opening lines of the book basically state that everything we do is determined by our thinking. But is it really? Not everyone seems to think so. While RenĂ©e des Cartes once said, “I think, therefore I am,” Alan Watts, who wrote another of our textbooks, The Way of Zen, emphasizes the Eastern way of thinking of “When I am not thinking, that is when I am.”
The Western thinkers demonstrated that thinking was meant to be an internal, singular process. Take Rodin's “The Thinker” statue, for instance.
Notice the man's posture. Not only is the statue of one solitary man, but his posture makes him appear to want to remain solitary. His face is serious. He is definitely deep in Western thought. Observe now a rendition of the Buddha.

The Eastern way of thought is through meditation. The Buddha's legs are folded into an open Lotus position. His hands are on his legs or in his lap, as if waiting for someone to join him or ask him a question. His face is serene, if not happy, and much less serious than the Thinker. This thinking position appears more enjoyable or inviting. Eastern meditation was meant to “link one with the universe” through thought.
But what does it all mean? What does this have to do with thinking critically or cultural bias even? When we know of and can recognize different types of bias, we can take precautionary steps against thinking in our normal way, and start changing the way we think toward a more open and fair-minded way. Which can be easier said than done, of course. It can be very difficult for someone to change the way they have been thinking throughout their lives, or let go of the emotional attachments they hold (Think of the refrigerator. Can someone really let go of something they feel is so valuable?). But it is still possible. We as thinkers must not expect something to be true based solely on its face value. One of our textbooks is biased, only I didn't realize it until we discussed it in class, and I'm sure it won't fully hit me until we start reading A Way of Zen, which we were given in order to balance out the biases. Cultural biases prevents different cultures from understanding one another, and if there is no understanding, then what will become of any culture? Of society in general?
Comments from the Instructors:
Melanie Wagner said...
Overall Grade: U
S
S
U - I'm impressed with your writing, see questions below
S
S
"In a modern, money-based society, we more often buy gifts to give to others." are other societies not modern?
"I'm sure it won't fully hit me until we start reading A Way of Zen, which we were given in order to balance out the biases." do you think biases can be balanced out?
Haley McClure said...
1.) All societies are inherently modern. With the exception of time zones, one does not need to time travel in order to see a different culture (for example, the Aborigines of Australia or the Amish Country in Northeast Ohio). While one may feel as though he or she is in a different time, all the calendars will still say “2009.” Unless of course that person is in North Korea, where the calendars will say “1998,” I believe. This is because the North Koreans have begun their calendar in 1912, the year in which their Eternal President Kim Il-Sung was born. (The reason is still a mystery to me. I'm sure it's a good one.)
Anyway, all societies are modern in that they all (with one exception) live in today's time. The “modern, money-based society” that I was referring to was the society in which I am currently living. This society is deemed “advanced” or “developed.” This society is money-based, while societies or nations which do not have as “advanced” an economy or standard of living are deemed “primitive,” uncivilized,” or the most “politically correct,” “developing.” I live in an advanced society. I use electricity every day. I own a computer, a cell phone, a television, and I even drive a car. I have hot, clean, running water every day. I have not known anything else my whole life. This does not make me more “modern” than someone living in another society. It makes me more “modernized.” It puts me under the category of “developed” rather than “developing.” I don't know how really to explain this without sounding prejudiced or super-defensive, but I hope it clears things up at least a little bit.
2.) The Paul and Elder book teaches Westernized thinking, while the Alan Watts book teaches Eastern thinking. It is my belief that Dr. Steel gave us these two books to create some sort of balance in what he is teaching and in what he wants us to learn. In a way, the biases of the authors are balanced, but the balance comes from learning about two ends of the thinking spectrum (and the two ways of thinking as well as just learning about them) rather than from the biases of the authors themselves.
SC Steel said...
Grade: (after revisions) S
More on Eastern thought soon.
Melanie Wagner said...
Good explication of your first point, Haley

No comments:
Post a Comment