Week #3
Would you rather wear the blue shirt, or the yellow shirt? Would you vote for raising taxes or police layoffs? Are there really only two choices? No. There are almost always more than two choices. Look in your closet. You have more than just a blue and a yellow shirt. The possibilities are endless there. The voting question is a bit more complex. This seems like a “lose-lose” situation. No matter which decision you make, someone will pay the price. There has to be another choice, right? This is a fallacy known as a dichotomy. A false dichotomy, to be specific. Many times, false dichotomies can come with another type of fallacy known as the “straw man” fallacy. This type of fallacy is designed to make one of your two given choices seem more obvious; the lesser of two evils. For example:
Would you rather raise taxes, or lay-off more police officers?
vs.
Would you rather raise taxes, or allow more criminals to run rampant through your city streets?
(Sometimes the phrase “think about your children,” or “your safety” is added for dramatic effect.)
It makes you see which choice the person asking you wants you to choose, doesn't it? In this type of situation, Dr. Steel warned us that the asker is trying to lure us into a trap. He told us that if we are only given two choices, the metaphorical “red flag” should appear, and we need to reflect before coming up with an answer. If we recognize the false dichotomy, then we should refuse to answer, and know that there could be one or more better solutions. We should ask both ourselves and the asker, “What other choices do I have?”
While we are reading, Dr. Steel informed us that the same “red flags” should appear if we are not given any supporting evidence, or if what we are given has been taken out of context. Take the Rush Limbaugh excerpt, for example. It is just that, an excerpt, and thus it was taken out of context by Dr. Steel. Also, the excerpt is missing some critical supporting evidence.
“One of the “expert” commentators for the networks during the televised hearings [of the Clarence Thomas/Anita Hill hearings] was Catharine MacKinnon, a law professor at the University of Michigan. She was just a fringe feminist before the hearings, but being presented as an analyst by the networks accorded her “expert” status. Ms. MacKinnon teaches, and I assume therefore believes, that all sex is rape, even sex in marriage. Women just don’t know it because they are in love and unaware of the power and denigration being heaped upon them. You laugh or disbelieve, but I assure you this is true. I don’t make things up. (p. 125)”
At face value, someone (like myself) would read this and wonder what may have brought Ms. MacKinnon to believe or teach such an extreme point of view. What we as readers are not informed of (if we didn't already know) is the level of prestige at the law school at the University of Michigan. Dr. Steel told us that the University of Michigan has one of the most revered law schools in the country. This already gives Ms. MacKinnon more credit than Mr. Limbaugh has given her. Added 9/17/2009 Paul and Elder would label Mr. Limbaugh's type of thinking in this situation "Activated Ignorance." On page 69, they define activated ignorance as, "Taking into the mind, and actively using, information that is false, though we mistakenly think it to be true." They continue by saying:
"Some people believe, through activated ignorance, that they understand things, events, people, and situations that they do not. They act upon their false ideas, illusions, and misconceptions, often leading to waste, pain, and suffering." Now, I don't think Mr. Limbaugh actually experienced any pain or suffering through his erroneous writings (or at least I hope not...) but the point got across to me that he had used his activated ignorance to write a book, or at least this excerpt from it, based on his own beliefs and assumptions which he thought were true (As in, "I believe it is true, therefore it must be true."). End Revision.
In 1995, a book was written in response to Limbaugh's book, that gives evidence to disprove Limbaugh's statements. The author wrote this of Catharine MacKinnon:
“-Wrote the definitive work on sexual harassment, Sexual Harassment of Working Women.
-Was co-counsel in the landmark Vinson case which set the legal standard for sexual harassment. (p. 52)”
This gives a reader substantial evidence that Ms. MacKinnon truly did deserve her title as “expert,” and she was not a “fringe” anything, certainly not a “fringe feminist.” Also, without substantial evidence from a primary source which tells us what Ms. MacKinnon actually taught, there is no absolute way to prove or disprove that she taught or even believed that radical idea about all sexual activities being rape, even intercourse within a marriage.
With the constant advances in technology throughout the world, it is becoming more and more easy for someone like myself to come to conclusions like this. Dr. Steel told us, “If you're not finding information, then you're not being given the right tools.” I certainly agree with this. Also, isn't it a matter of us utilizing the tools we have as well? I don't know if I would want to constantly rely on someone to give me what I need to obtain information. To me, part of the Critical Thinking process is to find information for ourselves rather than taking what we are told and analyzing only that. I believe that good thinkers are (or should be) encouraged to gather information from a number of sources (as opposed to what they are told by their teachers and peers) and come to conclusions based on both the reasons they are given and the reasons they discover for themselves. Otherwise, aren't we only thinking in a more fair-minded way, but still coming to the conclusions we are “supposed” to come to? Rather than doing our own research, coming up with our own conclusions, and actually thinking for ourselves?
Melanie Wagner said...
Overall Grade: U
S
U - please incorporate all readings
S
S
S
Haley McClure said...
Revised within post. Beginning and end of revision in bold.
SC Steel said...
Grade: (after revision) U
U Timeline discussion?
S
S
S
S
Haley McClure said...
I think there were two main points to the timeline discussion. One was to (once again) discover that there is a different side of history that we (as students) don't know about, or never learned. Or at least that we (as students) learned the "historical truth;" or "what really happened." We discussed that timelines are set up in strange ways. Before "year 0," only a few dates are provided. These few dates are the ones that experts have deemed "important" or "revolutionary." For example, the emergence of the first human life, or the Agricultural Revolution. After "year 0," this trend continues for a while until the timeline gets closer to the present, where the years and events show up more frequently.
I for one had always thought about the Agricultural Revolution in a (now) seemingly basic way. The early humans were hunter/gatherers, then they discovered it would be much easier to grow their necessary crops in one place and they became farmers. This led to them not needing to be nomadic, and they started to settle and stay in one place, because they had all they needed. This, then, led to the people having more "free" time for leisure and relaxation. I didn't know, or didn't realize, that most of what I had come to know as historical fact was untrue.
Which brings me to the next possible point. I believe the other point to the timeline discussion was to emphasize that change did not, and does not, happen immediately (or overnight). There are many gray areas in the advancement of the early humans. People didn't suddenly start settling down and farming all at once. Change is gradual. There are many civilizations today that have not "advanced." There are still tribes and nomads and indigenous people living in the world today as they have for thousands of years. We call them "primitive" and "uncivilized," but are they really? Or are they just less advanced than ourselves, or advancing more slowly?
Somewhere during the period of time called the Agricultural Revolution, there was a shift in peoples' thinking. The shift was in the relations between the people and their environment. Before, there were gods or forces of nature that controlled the lives of the people and the plants and animals around them. However, when early humans discovered that they could choose which plants they wanted to grow during certain times of the year, or which animals they could use for food and other things (like shelter, clothing, etc), it was the people who took control. Possesiveness even started to develop. There was a change from
THE land and THE food
to
MY land and MY food.
However, not all cultures were advancing in the same way or at the same rate. (At this point, the lecture began to tie in with the one that was to follow the next Monday) Take the Ancient Mayans. At the time, they were one of the most advanced civilizations in Mexico/Central America. They were well-known for their superb knowledge of mathematics and astronomy. They had an accurate, working calendar, and they lived in large, extravagant cities. From what we can tell, at least. When the Spanish arrived, they found the cities, the gold, the relics of an advanced people, but no people themselves. The Mayans had disappeared.
Today, there are people who are of direct Mayan descent. How can that be, if there were no Mayans left? Didn't they die out? No. The Mayans experienced no famine, and very little dealings with wars. We were told that in fact, the Mayans had “moved backward” on the timeline. They “gave up” their advanced civilization, their cities, and returned to being tribal nomads. Really, that is what saved them from the Spanish. And that is why they still exist today.
SC Steel said...
Grade: S
Sunday, March 7, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment